In Beloved, when a woman named Beloved
appears near Sethe’s house, she is welcomed inside and tended by Denver. Through
Paul D’s ambiguous vocabulary, Beloved’s simple language, and her striking physical
similarities to the baby Beloved, Toni Morrison suggests that Beloved might
either be a ghost or even a reincarnation of the baby Beloved. After Beloved
has fallen asleep on the chair, Paul D says: “‘You want to lay down a spell?’”
(64). The word “spell” could both signify the verb to sleep or to cast a spell.
Paul D’s ambiguous language might show that Beloved has supernatural power.
Although Beloved might have some kind of supernatural power, she also has close
similarities to the baby Beloved. When Paul D asks Beloved if she wants to
sleep, Beloved “stood up on her soft new feet which, barely capable of their
job, slowly bore her to the keeping room” (64). Beloved’s “soft new feet” are just
like those of a baby. Also, her weak legs further unveil her baby-like
features. Even her continuous sleeping is like that of an infant. Finally, her
simple and limited talk resembles that of a baby. When she arrives at Sethe’s
home, the only words she says are her name, and later when Denver asks “what is
it,” she responds “‘Heavy… This place is heavy’” (65). Therefore, Beloved’s few
words mirror those of a baby, and Beloved’s resemblance to the baby Beloved might
denote that she is a reincarnation of the baby Beloved or a ghost.
Caterina: I think you have a strong analysis and I love how you use the denotation of the word "spell" to explain an ambiguous word choice. But, I thought that your analysis jumped from point to point rather than flowing.
ReplyDeleteYou did a fantastic job of identifying and dissecting the multifaceted descriptions Beloved, but you seem to not go much farther than that. What purpose does this ambiguity between spiritual and physical play in reflecting the relationship of Beloved to the other characters in the narrative?
ReplyDelete